Welcome to Shafer Insurance Agency, Inc.

Established in 1900, Shafer Insurance Agency proudly provides comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Ohio. With over 120 years of service supplying the insurance needs of families and businesses, we are a trusted source for home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance and more. Whether you need to insure a car or a car dealership we have an insurance solution for you.

​

Full-Service Insurance Agency

Shafer Insurance provides all types of insurance protection. We can insure your personal insurance needs, such as your home, auto, boat, RV/Camper, ATV, jewelry or other valuables as well as personal umbrella coverage. If you have a farm, we can insure you too. We insure small businesses to large commercial accounts and write various types of bonds. We also write life and disability income insurance.

​

As an independent agency, Shafer Insurance Agency represents multiple insurance companies, which gives us the flexibility to offer you affordable prices and individualized options. 

​

Shafer Insurance has strived to put the client first and render service that is best for the policyholder. We welcome clients to stop in the office and pay their premium or review their coverage. We want you to feel welcome! When our agency was founded, we delivered policies on horseback. Although we don’t do that any longer, we still like the personal approach.